89 Comments
User's avatar
Noctua Magna's avatar

Solzhenitsyn, Aleksandr “200 Years Together” is an invaluable resource which confirms all of this. It is a book that is banned in English, but Russian and German translations are available.

Noctua Magna's avatar

I have this translation printed out and bound in my library.

longletters's avatar

Yes, props for highlighting that there are different versions in the wild. There is an earlier translation which if I recall, either misses the images or places them with some errors, so (just as with the Blood Passover translation) people are well advised to pay attention to which one they have.

Franz Kafka's avatar

Anyone who has not read that book cannot understand twentieth century European and American history. Thank God and Solzhenitsym for Western Samizdat.

Shlomo McFuckface's avatar

I wonder why i was never taught that in all my schooling….

Books Behind Borders's avatar

Hmm. Such a big mystery 🤔

Ronin's avatar

Oh, my. Good Lord. So it’s the Jews after all, more so than the City of London. Very compelling piece

longletters's avatar

Yes, and the notion that the Jews are subordinate to "empire" is just a cloak and subterfuge. There is not some willingness to be exposed, or commitment to the truth, ob that side. Only endless "look over there" distractions which are drawn from whatever's handy. If it's pointed out that the subterfuge is incoherent, handwaving or storms of words will ensue.

The majority of the denial of individuals and events in causal analysis--"everything boils down to systems theory: it's all systems, we have to destroy the systems"--is one such incoherency. It's not just a cloak and shield; it also serves the Bolsheviks in waiting. The new iteration of this self-interested group is poised in academia and business and government, to step in and take advantage whenever a "system" is destroyed. The lack of an obvious resort to violence is more due to the modernization of approach, which favors economic terrorism over physical brutality, as long as conditions are such that physical brutality can bring the law down upon them.

But note how quickly the situation in Palestine transformed from economic influence seeking (early 1800s to the dawn of the 1900s), to economic terrorism (mild in the 1st Aliyah, increasing with each Aliyah, until it became "state" policy to use as a constant means of suppression, beginning in 1926 with the Histradut's adoption of the South African isolation and exclusion along racial lines and becoming formal apartheid along with the so-called instantiation of "statehood" in 1948), to siege of Gaza in 2005 and "settler" carve-up of the West Bank from the 70s onwards, and now that they are certain the world will do nothing, they have abandoned economic terrorism and resorted to physical brutality. They aren't quite at the wanton physical violence seen in the 20s in Russia but if they can establish media blackout, my bet is, it's coming.

Expect the same arc anywhere they can establish a cordon of control.

How it begins:

Say a piece of an institution is defunded: civil society will suffer, or there will suddenly be a lack of a piece of society that was provided by that piece of institution.

Into the gap step the advantage takers, offering some new bureau or a public-private relationship, which serves power and bank accounts more than the recently destroyed piece ever did. Also, the networked relationships with the new substitute are more monolithic with, and ready to serve, those who put them into place.

Ronin's avatar

Maddie’s the bomb. We need more 30ish like her. Great comment!

longletters's avatar

I was so glad to find this exact article--knocks the socks off what I'd found on this topic so far!

Ronin's avatar

Nothing but crickets from Zionist-owned MSM. I would love to see a Substack advertising blitz to reel more normies in. However Maddie’s probably doing just that by advertising some offline I’d bet. That’s what I’d do if I wrote more / was more aggressive (just don’t have time)

longletters's avatar

I don't even know how that works, although surely some people are doing it because of how they are promoted when it's really not a great match for me *and* they happen to be names with a team behind them.

Franz Kafka's avatar

Exactly the scenario.

Jean Sweeny's avatar

Why has no strategy been found to combat those instructions that weren’t always written in disappearing ink. At this point the direct symptoms tied to these specific patterns have an obvious fingerprint, yet no strategic organized institution to surveil what has proven lethal time and again. That is nothing more than self imposed suicide.

longletters's avatar

I'm almost getting you, but not quite. To surveil? Instructions from whom to whom?

We did have fairly good albeit not perfect bulwarks, for a long time. For example we had strong resistance, not perfect but not at all nothing, in the Catholic church. Then came Vatican 2.

They are persistent and when attackers are persistent sometimes they will get through. They are obsessive, and have made paranoia and rageful "retaliation" against the imagined foe, one of their societal organizing principles. Meanwhile we do not organize ourselves that way, because we are not crazy and we enjoy other things in life. So we are not always on the offensive, which means we are usually on the defensive.

There are other phenomena at work as well, but I don't want to get too far into what I think, without understanding what you meant by those two phrases?

Ronin's avatar

Despite excellent journalists like Maddie (BBB) reaching millions more of us, most American citizens are willingly ignorant - willing believers in our government’s lies. I’d also argue that no one good in Trump’s admin and Congress has any real power. That makes it impossible to implement any kind of filter to weed out bad actors

longletters's avatar

Maddie's work is excellent.

There's a lot that can be said about our government, particularly a London banking move that took place during the gilded age.

In our government, a certain self understanding still prevailed, and did so at least until the mid century. It seems to me that the rise of the CIA was part of the shift and that was tied to the Zionists' increasing success at moving people into position.

Our State Department archives show the story, with the memos having to do with the Middle East being on a different and more well intentioned plane at the time of the Nakba.

For example here our top analyst points out that illegal negotiations from US citizens aimed at UN members was how the US ended up with a perceived responsibility to make the partition work https://history.state.gov/historicaldocuments/frus1948v05p2/d10

and here our analysts think that Truman should make recognition contingent on their forming a democratic government, which is to say, holding them to their promises https://history.state.gov/historicaldocuments/frus1948v05p2/d252

Also the Zionists' machinations show up, for example in documenting Chaim Weizmann's deceptions (in various memos from 1947-48) and also is bluntly described: in early May 1948, "the Jews will be the aggressors but will say they are defending" https://history.state.gov/historicaldocuments/frus1948v05p2/d210

is something we knew then, which the hasbara have worked hard to bury.

Imagine that being written by a career analyst today, and yet our various departments tried to hold the line right up to I would say this administration and the two preceding it. It was bad ever since 9/11 but now it's beyond all previous imagining and honestly I could wonder if they aim to return to some imagined 1500 BC.

This book is a capsule history of how that takeover happened and I think if anyone you know doesn't believe it because they have a hard time understanding how it could have happened, this is the book for them:

https://archive.org/details/weir-alison-against-our-better-judgment-the-hidden-history-of-how-the-u.-s.-was-_202404/page/n1/mode/1up There is also a website, ifamericansknew.org. It has some excerpts from this book, although it's very nice to see everything laid out in linear historical order.

There's always more that can be said. People and incidents mentioned by Weir have longer working histories than she can get into, for example Horace Kallen, whom I consider a very destructive Zionist who worked on us from the cultural angle.

Ronin's avatar

Max Blumenthal (Grayzone) had a great one on the CIA director who gave everything up for Israel; his name is on the tip of my tongue… It’s not an exaggeration to say that the Rothschilds, Israel and Epstein/Maxwell have been tragic for our country

Jean Sweeny's avatar

I apologize, I meant to infiltrate the enemy camp or those trying to ruin us. Those who have every tool to do so vs those who have none and appear to want none. That’s not a fight.

longletters's avatar

Hm, well, I think at each stage it has only looked like they are trying for this or that thing. Also as a group they have had "congresses" for centuries, which are meetings of their rabbis, and it is indeed those rabbis who are in control of the group. This is true up to the modern era, and then with their subjects wanting different things, it has been said that Zionism was one of the obsessions that turned out useful for keeping the masses in thrall to their organizing principles.

Since their meetings are always only between those who have gone through the intensive yeshiva training, and full membership is by birth (converts are not considered full Jews by the Israel rabbis), it's hard to see how such an infiltration could be made.

The medieval era was better at seeing their game for what it was. But we moved out of medieval ways of thought, and they learned that they could hold a mirror up to us, and tell us that we were seeing them. Not being medieval, we would not understand how untrue that is.

As for the practical side of things, it came on slow within our government and weak individuals were chosen for the application of pressure, or friendship, or whatever would be effective.

This book https://archive.org/details/weir-alison-against-our-better-judgment-the-hidden-history-of-how-the-u.-s.-was-_202404/mode/1up gives a tight little history of how that happened. It's very informative in only a hundred pages, kind of amazing really.

Jean Sweeny's avatar

Ambassador, Henry F. Grady is quoted here as saying…”With all my experience, I’ve never seen such disloyalty to the US. In the US, since there is no political force to counterbalance Zionism, its campaigns are bound to be decisive.”

longletters's avatar

That one stands out for you, too? Does it speak to exactly what you were asking about?

This whole quote you selected, just floored me when I read it. It still does tbh.

The "disloyalty to the US" ... for me, it clarified and cut through the excuses one can be inclined to, like, "well maybe there were extenuating circumstances". Nope...

Then add to that, that the lack of a political force is real, and has been a problem this entire time.

~~

It occurs to me, an article from the other day, with very good analysis and how-tos, could be relevant. I restacked it here with a tiny comment about being useful against hasbara: https://substack.com/@artsandletters/note/c-319958793

On reflection, and thinking about your question/criticism of the situation as it has gone on, I think this approach the author describes is probably useful in many irrational or manipulative attack situations. It's much broader than just political candidates or hasbara as I had thought at first. Could be helpful for the issue you pointed out?

He talks about having discipline to collectively work together and also I think his method demands personal discipline in countering their attacks, so as not to get sucked into being on defense or explaining oneself, and it requires some forethought, to cut to the underlying core of the problem and effectively keep holding them accountable and on the run. I think the discipline is also needed to stay on track and not get sucked into responding, to what I have heard called the "sorcery" of neurolinguistic programming and other psychological tricks used in verbal and political attacks.

Years ago there used to be lots of self-help books about how not to be victimized by this sort of manipulative twisty behavior. Sometimes I wonder why they fell out of fashion, in favor of high drama attitudes that encourage getting sucked in!

Jean Sweeny's avatar

Thanks so much for the suggestion. I get the sense that there are many who feel vulnerable and with good reason.

Jean Sweeny's avatar

Finally, victim status needs to be analyzed as to what it is and what it means regarding one’s actions.

When I was in 1st grade a kid sat next to me who wasn’t answering questions during a quiz so I showed him my answers and he told the teacher on me.

Jean Sweeny's avatar

Yes, the idea that we cannot counterbalance a seemingly inexorable future of usury, surveillance, investment bubbles (pre and post bursting) and to be used as fodder to fight foreign wars is absurd and illogical.

Darwin’s understanding of the human survival instinct has been threatened by false victimhood. The expectation is to either accept slave status or fight your opponent who is unbound while you’re bound and gagged. Lawyer’s and politicians work to codify this insanity b/c they achieve immediate gain and can focus on their individual profit.

It’s against natural law.

Franz Kafka's avatar

There is a difference already?!

Phil Smith's avatar

Given the large proportion of Jews in the first Bolshevik regime, why does it seem like they faded away as the Soviet Union developed?

Books Behind Borders's avatar

Hey Phil! Thanks for your comment / question. Personally, I don't see it this way at all. If you look hard enough, Jews are quite prevalent in Russia (Chabad). A ton also all came to the US and spread through Europe.

Phil Smith's avatar

I could accept that to some extent, but I doubt the proportion of Jews was as large later as it was at first.

Josie's avatar

"You must understand, the leading Bolsheviks who took over Russia were not Russians. They hated Russians. They hated Christians. Driven by ethnic hatred they tortured and slaughtered millions of Russians without a shred of human remorse. It cannot be overstated. Bolshevism committed the greatest human slaughter of all time. The fact that most of the world is ignorant and uncaring about this enormous crime is proof that the global media is in the hands of the perpetrators."

~Aleksander Solzhenitsyn

Franz Kafka's avatar

Not a revolution at all but a foreign financed regime change op.

Franz Kafka's avatar

The Jews and the Truth are not close friends for very good reason!

Books Behind Borders's avatar

Can you dispute any of the claims with evidence?

Promethean's avatar

These are cherry picked statistics and facts. And these are also talking points spouted by Nazis during WW2 for anti-soviet propaganda. It's the judeo-bolshevik conspiracy theory. Plenty of non Marxist historians would vouch for this.

Michel Martinez's avatar

It was the Jews who were behind Bolshevism Promethean.

Thom Dawson's avatar

So what are the non-Cherry picked statistics that you’re using to disprove the initial points?

Promethean's avatar

1. The Council of People's Commissars (1917): In the first composition of the Soviet government's highest executive body, out of 16 members, only one was Jewish (Trotsky).

2. The Bolshevik Central Committee: Of the 21 members of the Bolshevik Central Committee, only 5 were of Jewish descent. The most powerful figures, including Vladimir Lenin and Joseph Stalin, were not Jewish.

3. Overall Membership: In 1917, most Russian Jews were not Bolsheviks. The majority of Jewish socialists supported other groups, such as the Jewish Labor Bund or the Mensheviks, and many feared that Leninism would lead to violence. (Sachar, Howard M. (12 September 2006). A History of the Jews in the Modern World. Knopf Doubleday Publishing Group. p. 327.) Also see here, "According to the 1922 Bolshevik party census, there were 19,564 Jewish Bolsheviks, comprising 5.21% of the total, and in the 1920s of the 417 members of the Central Executive Committee, the party Central Committee, the Presidium of the Executive of the Soviets of the USSR and the Russian Republic, the People's Commissars, 6% were ethnic Jews." (Herf 2008, p. 96.)

4. Rejection of Judaism: The Bolshevik leaders who did have Jewish heritage, such as Trotsky, were secularists and internationalists who explicitly rejected Judaism, Jewish nationalism, and their own religious backgrounds. They viewed religion and nationalism as tools of the bourgeoisie. You can read any of their own works on this. Also, see the Yevsektsiya, a section in the communist party meant to turn religious Jews secular. And for example, Jewish properties such as synagogues were seized and rabbis were forced to resign. ("Russia". Encyclopaedia Judaica. Vol. 17. Keter Publishing House Ltd. pp. 531–553.)

There's just a few examples disproving these so-called "theories." If anything, it could be argued that the Soviet Union was anti-Semitic actually. Especially once Stalin began his targeted purges, (majority of them being Jewish intellectuals). Also let's think for a moment, why would Jews tend to support anti-Tsarist groups? Maybe because pogroms happened regularly under that regime? Maybe because the whites regularly massacred groups of Jews during the civil war? It's not rocket science. And you can look at this evidence but at the end of the day, I have a feeling evidence matters little to the OP of this article. They have an agenda firsthand. But please, I'd love to discuss this more if you're curious.

Thom Dawson's avatar

This this fantastic and I thank you I have a history degree and taught history but my concentration was mostly US and US intervention in South America and German states before 1871.

Anyway, sorry if my response seemed flipping because it was because you see people post what you said all the time without any backing of any kind.

I started looking into the references that you made in your post and I will continue to do so hopefully if I have a question I can put it out to you and maybe you can help me figure it out I think this is what Internet public discourse is supposed to be

Michel Martinez's avatar

Gentiles were not the ones who called the shots during the Revolution in Russia. In America Gentiles in our Gouvernment do the bidding of Organized Jewry. Jews are not numerous enough so they manipulate the uniformed Gentile masses.

Joseph Mobius's avatar

AI:

The 1922 Bolshevik party census shows Jews made up 5.21% of total members but held disproportionate power—6% of the Central Executive Committee, despite being less than 2% of Russia's population at the time. This overrepresentation in high-ranking positions aligns with historical claims of Jewish influence in early Soviet leadership.

Promethean's avatar

You must know you're being disingenuous, because the original claim is meant to argue that Jews have the majority or that they controlled or founded the Bolsheviks, no? The actual numbers even you showed don't suggest that.

Promethean's avatar

So a 0.8% difference between regular membership and executive committee? And a 3-4% difference between population and general membership? By technicality, yes, they were overrepresented, but what about the remaining 94% membership? Why do you think Jews might feel a little more inclined to support the Bolsheviks, the people who did not want to directly commit pogroms against them?

ED's avatar

THESE ISRAELI LYING JUBASTARDS ARE NOT EVEN FKN SEMITES. THEY ARE KHAZARIAN ASHKE"NAZI" FAKE JUBASTARDS WHO WERE FORCED TO TAKE 1 OF THE MAIN 3 RELIGIONS OF THE WORLD. THEY PICKED TO BE JEWS BUT THEY STILL WORSHIP SATAN, BAAL, BAPHOMET & ALL THE OTHER DEMONS FROM HELL. THEY TRAFFICK CHILDREN AROUND THE WORLD & SACRIFICE THEM TO THEIR DEMON GODS FOR POWER, WEALTH, FAME ETC. THE JEWS ARE FROM KHAZARIA- MODERN DAY UKRAINE, EASTERN EUROPE, POLAND LIKE SATANYAHU WHO GREW UP IN FKN JERSEY. MILEKOWSKI IS HIS REAL FKN NAME. IT'S TIME TO SEND THEM ALL BACK TO HELL WHERE THEY CAME FROM. 8 MILLION CHILDREN ARE KIDNAPPED & SOLD BY THESE KIKE MOTHER FUCKERS EVERY YEAR. TIME TO TURN THEM TO FKN DUST.

User's avatar
Comment removed
Jul 28
ED's avatar

BY THE WAY YOU JUBASTARDS STOLE PALESTINE IN A DEAL WITH THE SCUMBAG BRITISH. YOU STEAL LAND & HOMES EVERYDAY YOIU USELESS FKN DEMONS. YOU KILL BABIES BECAUSE YOU FEAR THEY WILL COME AFTER YOU IN THE FUTURE FOR KILLING THEIR FAMILIES & I HOPE THEY DESTROY ALL OF YOU SICK THINKING FUCKING PARASITES. IF IT WASN'T FOR THE DUMB FKS OF AMERIKA THEN ISRAEL WILL BE A SHIT STAIN ON THE BOTTOM OF THE WORLD. GET READY TO BE DESTROYED SCUMBAG. GEE I WONDER WHY THE FKN JUBASTARDS WERE THROWN OUT OF 130 COUNTRIESz? DEVIOUS, CONNIVING, LYING, THIEVES & MURDERERS. KHAZARIAN ASHKE"NAZI" FAKE JUBASTARDS FROM THE UKRAINE & EAstern europe who are not semitic at all. no wonder they forbide dna tests in nazi israhell. they would prove none of you mother fuckers come from the middle east. u r scum. THE SPAWN OF SATAN. HAHAHA YOU'RE ALL GOING TO BE DESTROYED JUBOY.

ED's avatar

GARYMMORON- THE FKN JEWS ARE THE SPAWN OF SATAN. THEY ARE DEVIOUS, SATAN WORSHIPPING, LYING, THIEVES OF LAND & PROPERTY & MOST OF ALL MASS MURDERING BABY KILLERS. ISRAEL IS BEING DESTROYED & BY THE END OF THE YEAR THESE FAKE JUBASTARDS WILL HAVE NO HOMELASND BECAUSE ALL THESE CUNTS WILL BE DEAD. ISRAEL CONTROLS IRAN & NUMEROUS GOVERNMENTS BUT THE FAKE JUBASTARDS OF ISRAEL ARE BEING SAVED FOR LAST....FOR DESTRUCTION. THATS WHY THE FKN PARASITIC BASTARDS ARE FLEEING ISRAHELL & GOING TO ARGENTINA JUST LIKE HITLER & VARIOUS OTHER COUNTRY THEY CAN SUCK DRY LIKE THE VERMIN THEY TRULY ARE. JEWS ARE THE WORSHIPPERS OF BAAL, BAPHOMET & OTHER OF HELL'S DEMONS. ALL BECAUSE THEY ARE GREEDY SCUM & CRAVE POWER WHILE ALL THE KIKES DRESS UP EXACTLY THE SAME & SMELL LIKE THE SHIT THEY ARE. ALL WHILE SACRIFICING CHILDREN TO THEIR DEMON gods. ISRAEL STARTED & FUNDS HAMAS YOU DUMB FUCK SO THEY CAN ATTACK THEMSELVES & THEN START MORE FKN WARS TO WIPE OUT THE MUSLIMS & CHRISTIANS. BOY YOU ARE 1 DUMB MOTHER FUCKER IF YOU DON'T KNOW THAT. GOYS WILL RULE SCUMBAG. HAHAHA GET READY FOR THE DESTRUCTION OF JULAND.

Sean Ambrose's avatar

Fantastic article Maddie.

The first autonomous jewish state was declared by Joseph Stalin in 1928. It is known as Birobidzhan and still exists to this day. Birobidzhan is in Russias far east.

Karl Marx was also not his real name. As I recall his real name was Moses Mordechai Levy and he is a descendant of Jewish rabbis by both his mother and father.

An interesting letter regarding the agenda of the Jews was sent to Karl Marx by Baruch Levy.

Of further interest is that the leadership of the Bolsheviks were not only Jews but they were also Freemasons. Between 1917 and 1924 the Bolsheviks had depicted the Swastika upon the 250 and 1000 Ruble banknotes. The Swastika is of importance to the Freemasons and particularly with the 7th degree of operative freemasonry.

poetry aside's avatar

You know, just at the outset, to jingle the communism evil bell, and then ting ting the sinister wandering Jew triangle seems way too much. Communism, to restate what should be obvious to any half brain not demented by the mania of privately owning common goods,is a philosophy in accord with the interdependence of all things and an affirmation of being over having, having squared with the fact that not even a trillion dollars will enable the pope to grant immortality to any sack of worm food however fashionably dressed. So forgive me if your opening volley sounds to me as incredible as the woo woo regularly vomited magisterially out at mega churches of jesus the humble trillionaire tramp, why don't you realistically address the issue of communism vs the disease of capitalism as argued in the works of the major exponents rather than splashing about like a spastic disciple of the master of the art of the crooked deal in a sea of errant nonsense? Ooh, not only do those dastardly commies want to socialise your panty liners, but they're all, oh my god, chosen people semites, shudder shudder shudder!

If only their damn jehovah would fire and brimstone the unabashed plethora of human stupidity into oblivion once and for all, the silence would be refreshing.

Stone's avatar

You don’t deny the crimes of the bolshevisk revolution do you, nor can you deny the majority make up of its most sinister expositors.

TL's avatar

33 degree master mason Albert Pike described this revelation to the letter in his letter about the three world wars.

TL's avatar

My point is that it’s the RCC and their Jesuits behind everything. The jews and freemasons are only their doers and assistants.

John Visher's avatar

Christopher Columbus was a Jew. He abused and killed first Americans who failed to bring him adequate gold. He cut off their hands. He drove entire families to suicide. Father, mother and children leaped from cliffs rather than live under Columbus’ brutal regime. Columbus enslaved 400 for his bankers in Europe. Crossing west to east 100 of the enslaved first Americans died, their bodies tossed into the see. What does this have to do with the Bolshevik Revolution? Jews and slavery pretty much explain western civilization for the last 2000 years.

Heretic Paradise's avatar

Alexandr Solzenitzen’s book 200 years together is an excellent resource on this subject. He called Naftaly Frenkel “the evil demon of the whole Archipelago.” He actually went from prisoner to Commandant and figured out how to make the slavery profitable. He even survived the purge and died an old man in Moscow. It’s truly amazing how many demons people have never heard of. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naftaly_Frenkel

Monnina's avatar

This still largely unknown Russian history in America is of real importance in the present day with a pro Russian Trump admnistration in the White House. However, there seem to be some serious numerical exaggerations in this piece.

During Stalin’s leadership during the 1930s, many of the old Bolshevik revolutionaries of Jewish background were targetted, demoted, imprisoned or executed during Stalin’s Great Purges.

Jews made up around 1% of the Russian population and approximately 5% of the Bolshevik party membership. Of the 21 members of the Bolshevik Central Committee in December 1917, only 5 members were from Jewish backgrounds.

AYA06's avatar

The conclusion I have come to is this,.... Blaming "Jewish involvement " in every aspect is also a facade. The global mafia that runs the world doesn't care about any religion. They play on all sides. They are luciferians who love loot, plunder, violence, bloodshed and massacre through division and hatred. They aim to enslave and humiliate. They don't care about humans whether Muslim, jew, Christian or any other religion. However playing the Jewish card serves them well on all fronts....Yes there are jews who serve their agendas but then there are many Christians, Muslims and Hindus low life soul sellers too. These are people who are operating at the lowest frequencies and invert all the laws of the Creator...Little they know that they will pay for it all sooner or later.......